MMATORCH

HOME | UFC NEWS | STRIKEFORCE | BELLATOR | WEC NEWS | ALL NEWS | PPVS | TV SHOWS | COLUMNS & BLOGS | SPECIALISTS
INTERVIEWS | ROUNDTABLES | RANKINGS & CHAMPS | UPCOMING EVENTS | DVD REVIEWS | ASK THE TORCH | FLASHBACKS | POLLS
WRITERS: PENICKAMADIENNIS B. HANSEN • PELKEYMATTHEWSSUTCLIFFE PEREZLEETHYDENKELLER

We're now an Android App!
Search "mmatorch"
(We're also an iPhone App)


UGO COVERS MMA

WE'RE A PROUD UGO AFFILIATE
SINCE 1999
Read Jonathan Snowden at UGO.com


MMATORCH CATEGORY JUMP MENU




Enter "MMATorch.com" in your phone's browser to get custom mobile version of this site!

Or click here to get our MMATorch Apple App (New 11/22!)



VISIT OUR AFFILIATE SITES

PWTorch.com
PRO WRESTLING NEWS & COMMENTARY
CLICK HERE

prowrestling.net
PRO WRESTLING NEWS & COMMENTARY
CLICK HERE


Opinion & Analysis : Penick's Take

PENICK: Rashad Evans vs. Rampage Jackson not a hindrance to an Evans title opportunity (rebuttal)


Jan 5, 2010 - 10:15:34 PM

By: Jamie Penick, MMATorch Editor-in-Chief

This evening, Anwar Perez made his Column debut here on the Torch with an argument that Rashad Evans should have been the one to face Lyoto Machida next, and that a combination of his pride to face Quinton "Rampage" Jackson after TUF 10 and Rampage's decision to film the A-Team movie is the reason that bout may not take place in 2010.

While it's clear that the Rampage departure delayed that particular bout, the fact of the matter is that Evans was not next in line had he fought Rampage in December, and would have likely needed another fight in 2010 before getting to a Title bout as it was.

The face time that went into the coaches feud during this season of the Ultimate Fighter necessitates that their bout take place as soon as possible. Mr. Perez makes a valid point that this bout has less significance in May than it would have last month, but it is not nearly to the level of the injury riddled debacle that became Hughes vs. Serra.

As to the issue surrounding Lyoto Machida's Light Heavyweight Title, it was not Rampage's acting turn that has kept Evans from being next in line, it was, quite simply, Mauricio "Shogun" Rua's performance at UFC 104 and the injuries suffered by Machida that have pushed Evans chance at a rematch back in time.

Most watching UFC 104 in October believed Rua won the bout, and at the very least believed it was such a close bout a rematch was in order. Dana White was one of them, and thus it was Rua being given another shot. With Machida needing surgery following the bout, the rematch has been pushed back to the expected May 1st date.

With that bout the next to happen, at the very least Evans would likely take a fight in the interim rather than take a six to eight month layoff to await the readiness of that fight's winner. With him, as Perez argues, deserving of a Title bout, if he is to take a fight in that timeframe it should be against no one less than Rampage.

This isn't pride taking over for Rashad Evans; he has no control over what match ups the UFC throws his way, as Anwar concedes. No, this is Rashad being a smart fighter and taking the only logical fight for him to take to get that shot to regain the belt he lost to Machida. With him fighting the same night as that Title fight, should he win, he will get the next Title fight as he would have won two straight since losing his belt. There's no other clear fighter to overtake him in the division at this moment and fighting Rampage is anything but detrimental to his career.

FAVOR: Would you help MMATorch by taking a short survey to create demographic info for our ad company? CLICK HERE

ALERT: Every Tuesday night, listen to the MMATorch Livecast from 9-10:30 p.m. ET or listen now to the most recent shows by clicking here. Listen live this coming Tuesday as Jamie Penick and Matt Pelkey discuss the latest MMA happenings. Online listen at http://www.blogtalkradio.com/mmatorch or call into the show at 646-716-8090 to either just listen or participate.

CLICK HERE FOR MORE UFC NEWS AND MMATORCH EXCLUSIVE FEATURES

BECOME AN MMATORCH VIP MEMBER FOR JUST $2.99 A MONTH, ELIMINATE ALL ADS, GET EXCLUSIVE CONTENT

Help support MMATorch by answering a brief anonymous demographic survey: CLICK HERE

Comment on this article below ad...






(CLICK FOR COMMENTS RULES OR TO REPORT ABUSE)

Comments

Alvin
05 Jan 2010, 23:38
Well put! Rampage is really the most logical fight. It makes perfect sense to me, and like you said Evan's does not really have a choice. Plus, the hype a few weeks for the fight will be anything but bad for the business. This is the type of fight casual fans and hardcore fans alike will be excited t see.
Jared
06 Jan 2010, 13:01
Why should Rampage have to even fight Rashad now? He was supposed to get that title shot against Rashad but Rashad said no, now Rashad NEEDS to fight Rampage more than Rampage needs to fight him.
Jared
06 Jan 2010, 14:05
"Why should Rampage have to even fight Rashad now?"

Maybe cause it was an advertised fight that was built up for months.

"He was supposed to get that title shot against Rashad but Rashad said no"

Are you saying that Rampage was supposed to get a title shot against Rashad and Rashad refused? Cause that's not true. Rampage became "no. 1 contender" after UFC 96, but was injured. So he dropped out of the proposed fight, and Machida stepped in. (All of which was covered in the original article)

"now Rashad NEEDS to fight Rampage more than Rampage needs to fight him."

That's true, cause Rashad is working his way back up to a title shot, and a victory over Rampage would get him there. If Rampage is going to re-retire after the fight, then of course Rampage doesn't "need" to fight him.
Tony
06 Jan 2010, 17:12
It has been stated that Rashad Evans turned down a fight with Rampage while he had the title. Rampage even brought it up during TUF.
Jared
06 Jan 2010, 19:15
Seriously, it was common knowledge that Rashad AS CHAMP CHOSE to turn down the Rampage fight.Seeing how Rampage defended his belt twice, he deserved a quicker shot, but Rashad thought Machida was a scrub. Notice how on the show when Rampage mentioned how Rashad turned down the fight in front of Jardine, and credited Jardine for stepping up, Rashad said nothing. Instead he fought a guy who is a gatekeeper risking number 1 contender status. Can't you see how Rampage was screwed in all of this? Since when does the number 1 contender and 2 time champion have to fight the guy who JUST lost the belt, AFTER that guy ducked him? Rampage was supposed to fight for the belt, not for some bad blood they made up by making Rashad get in Rampages face. Rashad even said White told him to do that.
terrence
07 Jan 2010, 01:54
"it was common knowledge that Rashad AS CHAMP CHOSE to turn down the Rampage fight."

actually it was Rampage that turned down the fight. Dana wanted him to fight Rashad at UFC 98 but he pulled out talking about how he needed surgery on his jaw, its on video too

"Rashad thought Machida was a scrub."

Rashad even said in a interview that he though Machida was better than Rampage, & everybody knows Machidas better than Rampage
James
07 Jan 2010, 04:17
These two blogs have been about how rampage will be a stepping stone to rashad's next title shot or how it will affect his title shot. Rampage is no pretender, he's a contender in his own right. Had this fight happened last month the winner would have got the next title shot. What happens if Rampage wins? does he get the next shot?? i would like to think so. sure rampage has had a long time between fights but hes a top fighter and one of the next in line, why is it assumed rashad will walk past him and get a title shot??
Jared
07 Jan 2010, 13:31
Dude are you serious? RAMPAGE WAS SUPPOSED TO FIGHT RASHAD AT UFC 96 BUT INSTEAD, HE CHOSE NOT TO. After saying no, OF COURSE he has no choice but to take the fight. Champs who do that lose their belt. If Rashad would've just taken that fight when he was supposed to, Rampage could've gotten the surgery afterward. Rampage was the number 1 contender, Rashad chose not to fight him but had no choice after he beat Jardine. Now Rashad knows in order to move ahead of the guy he was ducking he has to beat him. Im tired of arguing with uninformed people.
Jared
07 Jan 2010, 13:32
I meant to say instead Rashad chose not to fight rampage at ufc 96.
Jared
07 Jan 2010, 14:06
To me, it's somewhat irrelevant what happened before UFC 96. Rashad was going to fight Rampage at 98, but even more recently, at 107. That's why Rampage "NEEDS" to fight Rashad; that's a fight he agreed to.

I'm not saying that Rampage's issues with Dana are unsubstantiated, but no matter what valid reasons he had, he accepted a non-title fight against Rashad at 107. A similar situation happened with Henderson not getting a title shot against Silva. The difference is that Henderson addressed the issue immediately. Now personally, I would've loved to see Henderson fight Marquardt. However, Henderson didn't accept the fight because he felt he was due a title shot. If Rampage would've done the same thing, I would agree that Rampage doesn't need to fight Rashad. But Rampage didn't do that. He agreed to fight Rashad, in a fight that was promoted for months.

Should Rampage have had a title shot at 96? Yes. Could he have claimed that he was no. 1 contender after Rashad lost and been set up to fight Machida? Yes. But since he didn't, and he accepted a fight with Rashad, I think it's his job to do what he agreed to.
*Name:
Email:
Notify me about new comments on this page
Hide my email
*Text:
Security Image:

Visual CAPTCHA


 

(CLICK FOR COMMENTS RULES OR TO REPORT ABUSE)

CLICK TO RETURN TO MAIN LISTING
OR CHOOSE SPECIFIC CATEGORY LISTING FROM DROP MENU

MORE Penick's Take ARTICLES
PENICK: Randy Couture turns to the last run of his career after UFC 118 win over James Toney; should begin with Forrest Griffin or Rich Franklin
PENICK: Frankie Edgar had "The Answer" for a disappointing B.J. Penn at UFC 118
UFC 118 PREVIEW: Penick's breakdown and predictions for Edgar vs. Penn II and Couture vs. Toney event
PENICK: Bad officiating and no drug testing at "Strikeforce: Houston" showcase issues with the Texas Athletic Commission
PENICK: B.J. Penn vs. Kenny Florian II should be next if both fighters win at UFC 118
PENICK: Mirko Cro Cop's path back to heavyweight relevance fast tracked with UFC 119 opportunity against Frank Mir
PENICK: Georges St. Pierre vs. Anderson Silva the perfect headliner for the UFC's debut in Toronto at the Rogers Centre
BELLATOR 24 RESULTS: Penick's quick fight thoughts and ratings on tape delayed broadcast
PENICK: Anderson Silva's epic UFC 117 win an amazing comeback in the greatest title fight in UFC history
PENICK: Possible options to set up Anderson Silva vs. Chael Sonnen II without an immediate rematch
UFC 117 PREVIEW: Penick's breakdown and predictions of Silva vs. Sonnen event from Oakland
PENICK: Chael Sonnen gets caught in a lie, rides ridiculous denials into UFC 117
PENICK: Jon Jones needs a top tier opponent, how about Forrest Griffin at Fight Night 22?
PENICK: Brock Lesnar's UFC 116 victory reminiscent of heavyweight legends Nogueira and Emelianenko
UFC 116 PREVIEW: Penick's breakdown and predictions for Brock Lesnar vs. Shane Carwin event from Las Vegas
PENICK: A Fedor vs. Werdum rematch makes sense for the fighters but a terrible idea for Strikeforce
PENICK: Fedor's loss means the top fighter in each division now in the UFC
PENICK: Fedor Emelianenko's loss to Fabricio Werdum quite possibly the best thing to happen to Scott Coker
STRIKEFORCE AND M-1 GLOBAL: FEDOR VS. WERDUM PREVIEW: Penick's thoughts and predictions for Showtime event
PENICK: How Matt Hamill got cleared to fight with an apparent staph infection at The Ultimate Fighter 11 Finale

(c) 1999-2010 TDH Communications Inc. - All rights reserved.


Staff Picks - Top Ten Articles
UK SCENE: A bad week for UK fighters capped off at UFC 118; Daley's continued dismissal and UK news in brief
THE TAPPER'S TOOLBOX: Fixing the little mistakes in your BJJ game - "How to break guard"
PARK: A look at five era-changing losses by UFC Champions following B.J. Penn's UFC 118 loss to Frankie Edgar
ALL BUSINESS: The UFC 118 and Fan Expo Live Experience - Thoughts From a Fan Who Loves This Business
PENICK: Frankie Edgar had "The Answer" for a disappointing B.J. Penn at UFC 118
PARK: Randy Couture vs. James Toney at UFC 118 reminiscent of the initial UFC event's stylistic clashes
THE TAPPER'S TOOLBOX: Fixing the little mistakes in your BJJ game - "Mistakes Beginners Make – The Butterfly Sweep"
UK SCENE: Andre Winner and Nick Osipczak weigh in on UFC 118 bouts, Pickett vs. Jorgensen thoughts and more
AMADI: The good, the bad, and the ugly from "Strikeforce: Houston" on Showtime
PENICK: Bad officiating and no drug testing at "Strikeforce: Houston" showcase issues with the Texas Athletic Commission

ALSO: UFC PPV Reports: Results, analysis, fight ratings of all recent events



MMATorch Poll

Bjorn Rebney says not all MMA fans are NFL fans. Sound off, are you a fan of one sport alone or both?
I'm a fan of MMA but not the NFL
I'm a fan of both MMA and the NFL
I'm a fan of the NFL but not MMA
  

VOTE IN OR SEE RESULTS OF PREVIOUS POLLS

Artciles By Category


Staff Picks
UK SCENE: A bad week for UK fighters capped off at UFC 118; Daley's continued dismissal and UK news in brief
THE TAPPER'S TOOLBOX: Fixing the little mistakes in your BJJ game - "How to break guard"
PARK: A look at five era-changing losses by UFC Champions following B.J. Penn's UFC 118 loss to Frankie Edgar
ALL BUSINESS: The UFC 118 and Fan Expo Live Experience - Thoughts From a Fan Who Loves This Business
PENICK: Frankie Edgar had "The Answer" for a disappointing B.J. Penn at UFC 118
PARK: Randy Couture vs. James Toney at UFC 118 reminiscent of the initial UFC event's stylistic clashes
MMATorch Podcast
MMATORCH EXCLUSIVE: The Audio Choke with Collins, Rowland and Shelby 8/31 (52 min.) - UFC 118 event review and breakdown
VINTAGE AUDIO ('95): Keller interviews Dan Severn trainer after UFC 4, going behind the scenes at early UFC event (22 min.)
MMATORCH EXCLUSIVE: The Audio Choke with Collins, Rowland and Shelby 8/24 (102 min.) - Strikeforce Houston review and UFC 118 preview
MMATORCH EXCLUSIVE: Fighters and Writers audio with Carter, Hansen and McDermott (57 min.) - UFC 117 review and discussion
MMATORCH EXCLUSIVE: The Audio Choke with Collins, Rowland and Shelby 8/10 (85 min.) - UFC 117 review, Strikeforce Challengers and WEC 50 preview
MMATORCH EXCLUSIVE: The Audio Choke with Collins, Rowland and Shelby 8/3 (104 min.) - UFC on Versus 2 review, UFC 117 preview and more!
Upcoming Events
Bellator 27, September 2
Bellator 28, September 9
Shark Fights 13, September 11
UFC Fight Night 22, September 15
Bellator 29, September 16
Bellator 30, September 23
MMA News
BELLATOR NEWS: Joe Soto says "dirt bag" Joe Warren only better than him at s*** talking ahead of Bellator 27 meeting
UFC NEWS: FightMetric named the official statistics provider of the UFC
UFC 118 SALARIES: James Toney tops disclosed payroll with $500,000 for his three minute loss to Randy Couture
UFC NEWS: Alan Belcher undergoes another eye surgery for "blurry vision"
UFC NEWS: Gabe Ruediger to get one more shot in the UFC after one-sided UFC 118 loss to Joe Lauzon
BELLATOR NEWS: Weigh-in results for Bellator Fighting Championships 27
PPV & TV Events
KELLER'S UFC 118 BLOG: Toney vs. Couture, Edgar vs. Penn... Random Thoughts in Chronological Order
UFC 118 RESULTS: Penick's live round by round report of Edgar vs. Penn II, Couture vs. Toney event from Boston
UFC 118 Prediction and Betting Contests
STRIKEFORCE: HOUSTON RESULTS - Ronaldo "Jacare" Souza captures vacant Middleweight Championship with decision win over Tim Kennedy
STRIKEFORCE: HOUSTON RESULTS - Penick's live round by round report of King Mo vs. Feijao event on Showtime
BELLATOR 25 RESULTS: Pelkey's live round by round report of Horbuckle vs. Blackburn headlined event from Chicago
TV Reviews
THE ULTIMATE FIGHTER REPORT 6/9: Hyden's (Virtual Time) rundown of all the fights, all the drama in a 2 hour episode on Spike TV
THE ULTIMATE FIGHTER REPORT 6/2: Hyden's (Virtual Time) rundown of all the fights, all the drama on Spike TV
THE ULTIMATE FIGHTER REPORT 5/26: Hyden's rundown of all the fights, all the drama on Spike TV
THE ULTIMATE FIGHTER REPORT 5/19: Hyden's (Virtual Time) rundown of all the fights, all the drama on Spike TV
THE ULTIMATE FIGHTER REPORT 5/12: Hyden's rundown of all the fights, all the drama on Spike TV
THE ULTIMATE FIGHTER REPORT 5/5: Hyden's (Virtual Time) rundown of all the fights, all the drama on Spike TV
Live Event Reports
BELLATOR 26 RESULTS: Carter's Live Report - Heavyweight, Bantamweight, and Women’s 115 lbs. Quarterfinal Tournament Bouts
STRIKEFORCE: HOUSTON RESULTS - Unaired preliminary card results for event from the Toyota Center
BELLATOR 24 RESULTS: Carter's Live Report - Season Three Debut Show
LOCAL SCENE: First round finishes abound at "Combat on Capitol Hill 2" in St. Paul, MN
LOCAL SCENE: Havoc at the Hyatt II brings good fights and controversy to Minneapolis on Saturday night
BELLATOR 21 RESULTS: Carter's Report of the Lightweight Tournament Finals
Opinion & Analysis
UK SCENE: A bad week for UK fighters capped off at UFC 118; Daley's continued dismissal and UK news in brief
ROUNDTABLE (pt. 1): What's next for B.J. Penn and Kenny Florian after their UFC 118 losses? Marsh, Hyden, Hobaugh, Leet and Hansen
THE TAPPER'S TOOLBOX: Fixing the little mistakes in your BJJ game - "How to break guard"
HYDEN BLOG: Change Can Be A Good Thing
PARK: A look at five era-changing losses by UFC Champions following B.J. Penn's UFC 118 loss to Frankie Edgar
ALL BUSINESS: The UFC 118 and Fan Expo Live Experience - Thoughts From a Fan Who Loves This Business
Interviews
STRIKEFORCE QUOTABLES: Muhammed "King Mo" Lawal says he deserved to lose to Rafael "Feijao" Cavalcante because he abandoned his gameplan
QUOTABLES: Paul Daley says UFC "God" Dana White rules the UFC with an iron rod
UFC QUOTABLES: Lightweight Champion Frankie Edgar says he's fine with fans taking time to believe in him after consecutive wins over B.J. Penn
QUOTABLES: Shaquille O'Neal says he wants to fight one MMA fight against Hong Man-Choi
BELLATOR NEWS: Travis Reddinger credits trainer Sergio Cunha for his progression; ready for "explosive" bantamweight tournament
UFC QUOTABLES: UFC welterweight and former pro boxer Marcus Davis doesn't think James Toney will be able to do anything at UFC 118
Champs & Rankings
UFC 118: Edgar vs. Penn II Prediction and Betting Contest Results
MMATorch Staff Rankings - August 2010
UFC 117 Prediction and Betting Contest Results
UFC 116: Lesnar vs. Carwin Prediction and Betting Contests Results
MMATorch Staff Rankings - July 2010
UFC 115 Prediction and Betting Contest Results
Ask the Torch
Ask MMATorch: Answers to your questions about Shamrock, Half vs. Full Guard, Hammill, UFC Pay
DVD Reviews
DVD REVIEW: "UFC: Rampage Greatest Hits" a great collection of fights for Rampage fans new and old
DVD WORLD: Pride 33 "The Second Coming" - Dan "Hollywood" Henderson vs. Wanderlei "The Axe Murderer" Silva (pt. 8)
DVD WORLD: Pride 33 "The Second Coming" - Nick Diaz vs. "The Fireball Kid" Takanori Gomi (pt. 7)
DVD WORLD: Pride 33 "The Second Coming" - Alistair "Ubereem" Overeem vs. Mauricio "Shogun" Rua (pt. 6)
DVD WORLD: Pride 33 "The Second Coming" - Sergei Kharitonov vs. Mike Russow (pt. 5)
DVD WORLD: Pride 33 "The Second Coming" - Hayato "Mach" Sakurai vs. Mac Danzig (pt. 5)
Torch Flashbacks
FLASHBACK: Keller's full fight report and more Dana White quotes on UFC's debacle of an event back in 2001
KELLER: Dana White had a night even worse than Strikeforce's on Saturday night back in 2001
FLASHBACK (3 YRS AGO): Keller's UFC 69 Report with Georges St. Pierre vs. Matt Serra, Koscheck vs. Sanchez, Huerta vs. Garcia
ENNIS (Flashback 2006): Pride vs. UFC: Which Aspects of Each Promotion Would You Keep?
FLASHBACK - 3 YRS AGO: Ennis's UFC 67 Report - Rampage and Cro Cop debut, Anderson Silva defends, Scott Smith, Roger Huerta
1 YR AGO - PENICK'S UFC 88 REPORT: Rashad Evans vs. Chuck Liddell, Rich Franklin vs. Matt Hamill, plus Hendo, Marquardt (w/star ratings)
Torch MMA Polls
MMATORCH POLL: Bellator CEO Bjorn Rebney says not all MMA fans are NFL fans. Be heard, are you a fan of one sport alone or both?
NEW MMATORCH POLL: Who should Anderson Silva face next?
POLL: Should Liddell retire or fight again? Should Cro Cop retire or fight again?
MMATORCH POLL: Which fight are you anticipating more - Lesnar vs. Carwin or Silva vs. Sonnen?
POLL: What should Paul Daley's punishment be for the post-fight cheapshot at Koscheck?
MMATORCH POLL: Who will win and how in the UFC 113 main event between Lyoto Machida and Mauricio "Shogun" Rua
Prediction and Betting Contests
UFC 118: Edgar vs. Penn II Prediction and Betting Contest Results
UFC 118 Prediction and Betting Contests
UFC 117 Prediction and Betting Contest Results
UFC 117: Silva vs. Sonnen Prediction and Betting Contests


© 1999-2010 TDH Communications Inc. • All rights reserved -- PRIVACY POLICY