MMATORCH

HOME | UFC NEWS | STRIKEFORCE | BELLATOR | WEC NEWS | ALL NEWS | PPVS | TV SHOWS | COLUMNS & BLOGS | SPECIALISTS
INTERVIEWS | ROUNDTABLES | RANKINGS & CHAMPS | UPCOMING EVENTS | DVD REVIEWS | ASK THE TORCH | FLASHBACKS | POLLS
WRITERS: PENICKAMADIENNIS B. HANSEN • PELKEYMATTHEWSSUTCLIFFE PEREZLEETHYDENKELLER

We're now an Android App!
Search "mmatorch"
(We're also an iPhone App)


UGO COVERS MMA

WE'RE A PROUD UGO AFFILIATE
SINCE 1999
Read Jonathan Snowden at UGO.com


MMATORCH CATEGORY JUMP MENU




Enter "MMATorch.com" in your phone's browser to get custom mobile version of this site!

Or click here to get our MMATorch Apple App (New 11/22!)



VISIT OUR AFFILIATE SITES

PWTorch.com
PRO WRESTLING NEWS & COMMENTARY
CLICK HERE

prowrestling.net
PRO WRESTLING NEWS & COMMENTARY
CLICK HERE


Opinion & Analysis : Hyden's Take

HYDEN BLOG: B.J. Penn Has Made The Lightweight Division Irrelevant


Dec 18, 2009 - 12:49:50 PM
By Frank Hyden, MMATorch Contributor
Note: I would have made this a longer blog, but I'm too busy celebrating that amazing Colts win last night. It almost didn't happen, but 14-0 is a tremendous feat. They only have the Jets and Bills left, here's hoping they do it, if for no other reason than to shut up the '72 Dolphins for good.

B.J. Penn is one of the best fighters in the world. He was already considered as such previously, but his beatdown of Diego Sanchez reconfirmed it. To me, the top 5 fighters in the world are BJ Penn, Georges St. Pierre, Anderson Silva, Fedor Emelianenko, and Miguel Torres. I know Torres just lost, but this is MMA, everyone loses. Brian Bowles caught Torres with a surprise counter-punch that lead to his victory. I take nothing away from what Bowles did, he earned that win. If they fight again, it's more likely that Torres would win, but Bowles might pull the upset again. Regardless, I don't think Lyoto Machida has done enough to wedge out Torres on that list.

I think Lightweight is the best weight class for B.J. in the UFC. The reason I think that is BJ has to cut a lot more weight to make the 155 pound weight limit for that division. B.J.'s problem has always been his conditioning. However, in his last 2 fights, B.J. has shown much improved conditioning. I'm not really sure where UFC should go with B.J.'s next opponent. You could make a case for Frank Edgar getting the title shot. You could give the winner of the upcoming Gray Maynard vs. Nate Diaz fight the title shot. The problem is that I think B.J. would beat the hell out of any of those three. This is the same problem that the UFC is having with Anderson Silva. There's a lot of good Lightweights, but none stand out as being able to beat B.J. consistently. Sure, any one of them could beat B.J. on a given night, but it's more likely that B.J. will beat them down and then tap them out. Can anyone beat B.J., with the way he's fighting now?

Who would you all like to see BJ Penn fight next? Post in the Comments section below, or e-mail me at hydenfrank@gmail.com

Follow me at www.twitter.com/hydenfrank or find me on Facebook

FAVOR: Would you help MMATorch by taking a short survey to create demographic info for our ad company? CLICK HERE

ALERT: Every Tuesday night, listen to the MMATorch Livecast from 9-10:30 p.m. ET or listen now to the most recent shows by clicking here. Listen live this coming Tuesday as Jamie Penick and Matt Pelkey discuss the latest MMA happenings. Online listen at http://www.blogtalkradio.com/mmatorch or call into the show at 646-716-8090 to either just listen or participate.

CLICK HERE FOR MORE UFC NEWS AND MMATORCH EXCLUSIVE FEATURES

BECOME AN MMATORCH VIP MEMBER FOR JUST $2.99 A MONTH, ELIMINATE ALL ADS, GET EXCLUSIVE CONTENT

Help support MMATorch by answering a brief anonymous demographic survey: CLICK HERE

Comment on this article below ad...






(CLICK FOR COMMENTS RULES OR TO REPORT ABUSE)

Comments

Cole Bratcher
18 Dec 2009, 13:37
The only way I see BJ penn losing lightweight right now is if we have a match like:

Diego Sanchez and Kenny Florian vs. BJ Penn.

Godric
18 Dec 2009, 15:12
I agree wiv you on the top five fighters in mma right now but i would keep my eye on Jose Aldo, i've seen all his professional fights n he looks like he will join the mma elite, as for BJ i c no one currently in lightweight that can beat him having said that mayb a 10 lb heavier aldo cud do something
Jared
18 Dec 2009, 15:52
First off, totally agree about the Colts and '72 Dolphins. That's why I'm rooting for Indy and New Orleans to go 18-0. Then someone would be guaranteed to leave the Super Bowl undefeated. And it would be even sweeter since it's in Miami. If they both beat the odds, they should seat the '72 Dolphins front row to watch their record come crumbling down.

Secondly, completely agree about BJ. I just don't see anyone challenging him. I partially agree with you about Silva, yeah he's going to be favored against anyone, but Marquardt and Belfort (and maybe eventually Maia) are more of a challenge than Edgar or Maynard. Anderson has some interesting matchups, I just don't find anyone that interesting for BJ.
matt6buckeye
18 Dec 2009, 16:13
I was telling a friend the other day that BJ has basically dominated the four biggest names/interesting challenges in the division in his last four fights at 155. He beat Joe Daddy to win the belt and then defended against Sherk, Florian, and Sanchez. Is anyone really interested in seeing Penn do the same against Gray Maynard? Frankie Edgar? Tyson Griffin? Not me. Now is the time for Penn to give up the belt, take 7-8 months off to properly put on the weight, and move up to 170. Having Marv Marinovich as your strength and conditioning coach will help out in that regard.

His first fight at 170 could be Penn/Hughes III and could headline the summer Hawaii show. Then give him one of the (next)big-3: Koscheck, Alves, Fitch. If he wins those two fights then he's earned another crack at GSP. Then that leaves the lightweight division to Sherk, Florian, Sanchez, Stevenson, Maynard, Edgar, and Griffin to determine a new lightweight champ. Add in one more fighter (Escudero, Lauzon, Diaz?) and how great would an eight man tournament to crown a new lightweight champ fought throughout 2010 be? Crown the new champ at the 2010 year end show. I know the UFC hates tournaments, but this would never involve a fighter fighting twice in one night. It would allow the public to follow it throughout an entire year, making the winner the new "the guy" at 155.
Jared
18 Dec 2009, 16:50
matt6buckeye- I wouldn't dislike seeing what you've mentioned, but I honestly don't see BJ challenging GSP. Their last fight didn't give me the impression that a different game plan, or tweaking a few things (such as getting up to 170 progressively) would make a difference. GSP dominated BJ. BJ's takedown defense is ridiculous, however, GSP's takedown is more so. I'm just not sure BJ can do much on the ground against GSP. I think Florian would have a better shot against BJ than BJ would have against GSP.
Trend Tracker
18 Dec 2009, 22:58
Bj will always beat anyone the same size or smaller than him. GSP will kill him if he goes up in weight again.

The Colts and the Saints will be at home watching San Diego and Minnesota play in the Super Bowl.
Mark
19 Dec 2009, 13:48
Amazing colts win? over the middling jaguars? c'mon, you should have beaten those guys by at least the same margin you beat the titans, who ran all over jacksonville.

-M of Jacksonville (Dolphin's fan)
Frank Hyden
19 Dec 2009, 14:08
Trend Tracker, I hope you're not counting on Favre to lead the Vikes to the SB. If Minnesota makes it, it'll be because of Peterson and that defense. Favre is going to start throwing interceptions in the playoffs, and I think that's going to cost them. Especially if Darren Sharper or the other Saints get ahold of them.
Mark, let's give the Jags some credit. MJD is a really good runner and David Garrard played a good game until the 4th.
Matt, a tournament sounds great to me. I'm definitely down for that.
Cole
19 Dec 2009, 14:47
Come on guys, talk about football at some other website. This is MMA torch.

I don't think it's impossible for Penn to beat GSP if given another shot. Granted it won't be easy, but the problem with him has been his conditioning and it seems to me he's turned over a new leaf in that regard. It will be one hell of a fight either way.

Also I considered Jose Aldo as well, but I think BJ will just be too big for him. I mean BJ did have the Welterweight belt at one point. If he's big enough to fight in a bigger weight class than he's too big for Aldo. It's kinda like what White said about GSP and A Silva fighting against each other. If Anderson is able to Kick ass at light heavyweight, he's too big for GSP.
Jared
19 Dec 2009, 15:46
"If Anderson is able to Kick ass at light heavyweight, he's too big for GSP."

I agree with this, and it's possible that this might apply to GSP-Penn as well. If GSP does move up to MW, and dominates everyone there (assuming Anderson moves up), then he's too big for BJ.

If the new BJ translated to 170, then he would probably put up a better fight, but I still don't see him winning. GSP is bigger, and he shoots in too fast for even Penn. I don't think Penn having better cardio will be able to stop GSP from taking him down.
Cole
19 Dec 2009, 18:32
I can't argue with that. Has GSP ever fought at middleweight? If he starts kicking ass there then I'll have to agree that BJ doesn't stand a chance.

It would still be a fun fight to watch though. Upsets happen.
Jared
19 Dec 2009, 23:45
I'm pretty sure GSP has never fought at Middleweight.

And yeah, BJ winning would be fun to watch (which is what I wanted to happen). Not that I dislike GSP, I just like Penn better. And since GSP is so dominant, Penn winning would shake things up. Outside of Penn knocking off 3 Welterweight contenders, and then getting a rematch against GSP, GSP moving up to Middleweight definitely provides the more interesting matchups.
magster
05 Jan 2010, 15:44
Although I agree that BJ dominates the 155 and should move up to 170 I wouldn't want to see him do it until he fights Frankie Edgar He has been the underdog in almost everyone of his fights and comes back and beats big names He deserves a chance
*Name:
Email:
Notify me about new comments on this page
Hide my email
*Text:
Security Image:

Visual CAPTCHA


 

(CLICK FOR COMMENTS RULES OR TO REPORT ABUSE)

CLICK TO RETURN TO MAIN LISTING
OR CHOOSE SPECIFIC CATEGORY LISTING FROM DROP MENU

MORE Hyden's Take ARTICLES
HYDEN BLOG: Change Can Be A Good Thing
HYDEN BLOG: Time To Do Away With Lay-And-Pray, The Art Of Bore
HYDEN BLOG: Thoughts on Randy Couture vs. James Toney; Plus Reader Feedback
HYDEN BLOG: I'm Glad Anderson Silva Beat Chael Sonnen
HYDEN BLOG: Chael Sonnen Has A Lot of Bark, Probably Not Much Bite
HYDEN BLOG: Looking Ahead To The Next "Biggest Event In MMA History", UFC 121
HYDEN BLOG: Thoughts on Jake Shields, James Toney, Brock Lesnar and Ken Shamrock
HYDEN BLOG: An Early Read on Anderson Silva vs. Chael Sonnen; Plus Reader Feedback On Lesnar vs. Carwin
HYDEN BLOG: Brock Lesnar vs. Shane Carwin Point/Counterpoint
HYDEN BLOG: UFC 116 Quick Picks and a Reader E-mail
HYDEN BLOG: Thoughts on Brock Lesnar vs. Shane Carwin, Bad Officiating, and Frank Shamrock
HYDEN BLOG: Batista Going To Strikeforce Will Probably Be A Mistake
HYDEN BLOG: Thoughts On Chuck Liddell and The Ultimate Fighter Finale 11
HYDEN BLOG: UFC 115 a Possibly Good Card, Though Very Skippable; Reader Response From Last Week
HYDEN BLOG: Why Are MMA Fighters So Underpaid?
HYDEN BLOG: The Art Of The Flop
HYDEN BLOG: Thoughts on Overeem after "Strikeforce: Heavy Artillery" and on a potential Rua vs. Couture match up
HYDEN BLOG: Looking at UFC 113's eventful evening
HYDEN BLOG: The Myth Of The Gracie Dynasty, And Reader Feedback
HYDEN BLOG: Reader Potpourri About Georges St. Pierre, James Toney, and Strikeforce

(c) 1999-2010 TDH Communications Inc. - All rights reserved.


Staff Picks - Top Ten Articles
UK SCENE: A bad week for UK fighters capped off at UFC 118; Daley's continued dismissal and UK news in brief
THE TAPPER'S TOOLBOX: Fixing the little mistakes in your BJJ game - "How to break guard"
PARK: A look at five era-changing losses by UFC Champions following B.J. Penn's UFC 118 loss to Frankie Edgar
ALL BUSINESS: The UFC 118 and Fan Expo Live Experience - Thoughts From a Fan Who Loves This Business
PENICK: Frankie Edgar had "The Answer" for a disappointing B.J. Penn at UFC 118
PARK: Randy Couture vs. James Toney at UFC 118 reminiscent of the initial UFC event's stylistic clashes
THE TAPPER'S TOOLBOX: Fixing the little mistakes in your BJJ game - "Mistakes Beginners Make – The Butterfly Sweep"
UK SCENE: Andre Winner and Nick Osipczak weigh in on UFC 118 bouts, Pickett vs. Jorgensen thoughts and more
AMADI: The good, the bad, and the ugly from "Strikeforce: Houston" on Showtime
PENICK: Bad officiating and no drug testing at "Strikeforce: Houston" showcase issues with the Texas Athletic Commission

ALSO: UFC PPV Reports: Results, analysis, fight ratings of all recent events



MMATorch Poll

Bjorn Rebney says not all MMA fans are NFL fans. Sound off, are you a fan of one sport alone or both?
I'm a fan of MMA but not the NFL
I'm a fan of both MMA and the NFL
I'm a fan of the NFL but not MMA
  

VOTE IN OR SEE RESULTS OF PREVIOUS POLLS

Artciles By Category


Staff Picks
UK SCENE: A bad week for UK fighters capped off at UFC 118; Daley's continued dismissal and UK news in brief
THE TAPPER'S TOOLBOX: Fixing the little mistakes in your BJJ game - "How to break guard"
PARK: A look at five era-changing losses by UFC Champions following B.J. Penn's UFC 118 loss to Frankie Edgar
ALL BUSINESS: The UFC 118 and Fan Expo Live Experience - Thoughts From a Fan Who Loves This Business
PENICK: Frankie Edgar had "The Answer" for a disappointing B.J. Penn at UFC 118
PARK: Randy Couture vs. James Toney at UFC 118 reminiscent of the initial UFC event's stylistic clashes
MMATorch Podcast
MMATORCH EXCLUSIVE: The Audio Choke with Collins, Rowland and Shelby 8/31 (52 min.) - UFC 118 event review and breakdown
VINTAGE AUDIO ('95): Keller interviews Dan Severn trainer after UFC 4, going behind the scenes at early UFC event (22 min.)
MMATORCH EXCLUSIVE: The Audio Choke with Collins, Rowland and Shelby 8/24 (102 min.) - Strikeforce Houston review and UFC 118 preview
MMATORCH EXCLUSIVE: Fighters and Writers audio with Carter, Hansen and McDermott (57 min.) - UFC 117 review and discussion
MMATORCH EXCLUSIVE: The Audio Choke with Collins, Rowland and Shelby 8/10 (85 min.) - UFC 117 review, Strikeforce Challengers and WEC 50 preview
MMATORCH EXCLUSIVE: The Audio Choke with Collins, Rowland and Shelby 8/3 (104 min.) - UFC on Versus 2 review, UFC 117 preview and more!
Upcoming Events
Bellator 27, September 2
Bellator 28, September 9
Shark Fights 13, September 11
UFC Fight Night 22, September 15
Bellator 29, September 16
Bellator 30, September 23
MMA News
BELLATOR NEWS: Joe Soto says "dirt bag" Joe Warren only better than him at s*** talking ahead of Bellator 27 meeting
UFC NEWS: FightMetric named the official statistics provider of the UFC
UFC 118 SALARIES: James Toney tops disclosed payroll with $500,000 for his three minute loss to Randy Couture
UFC NEWS: Alan Belcher undergoes another eye surgery for "blurry vision"
UFC NEWS: Gabe Ruediger to get one more shot in the UFC after one-sided UFC 118 loss to Joe Lauzon
BELLATOR NEWS: Weigh-in results for Bellator Fighting Championships 27
PPV & TV Events
KELLER'S UFC 118 BLOG: Toney vs. Couture, Edgar vs. Penn... Random Thoughts in Chronological Order
UFC 118 RESULTS: Penick's live round by round report of Edgar vs. Penn II, Couture vs. Toney event from Boston
UFC 118 Prediction and Betting Contests
STRIKEFORCE: HOUSTON RESULTS - Ronaldo "Jacare" Souza captures vacant Middleweight Championship with decision win over Tim Kennedy
STRIKEFORCE: HOUSTON RESULTS - Penick's live round by round report of King Mo vs. Feijao event on Showtime
BELLATOR 25 RESULTS: Pelkey's live round by round report of Horbuckle vs. Blackburn headlined event from Chicago
TV Reviews
THE ULTIMATE FIGHTER REPORT 6/9: Hyden's (Virtual Time) rundown of all the fights, all the drama in a 2 hour episode on Spike TV
THE ULTIMATE FIGHTER REPORT 6/2: Hyden's (Virtual Time) rundown of all the fights, all the drama on Spike TV
THE ULTIMATE FIGHTER REPORT 5/26: Hyden's rundown of all the fights, all the drama on Spike TV
THE ULTIMATE FIGHTER REPORT 5/19: Hyden's (Virtual Time) rundown of all the fights, all the drama on Spike TV
THE ULTIMATE FIGHTER REPORT 5/12: Hyden's rundown of all the fights, all the drama on Spike TV
THE ULTIMATE FIGHTER REPORT 5/5: Hyden's (Virtual Time) rundown of all the fights, all the drama on Spike TV
Live Event Reports
BELLATOR 26 RESULTS: Carter's Live Report - Heavyweight, Bantamweight, and Women’s 115 lbs. Quarterfinal Tournament Bouts
STRIKEFORCE: HOUSTON RESULTS - Unaired preliminary card results for event from the Toyota Center
BELLATOR 24 RESULTS: Carter's Live Report - Season Three Debut Show
LOCAL SCENE: First round finishes abound at "Combat on Capitol Hill 2" in St. Paul, MN
LOCAL SCENE: Havoc at the Hyatt II brings good fights and controversy to Minneapolis on Saturday night
BELLATOR 21 RESULTS: Carter's Report of the Lightweight Tournament Finals
Opinion & Analysis
UK SCENE: A bad week for UK fighters capped off at UFC 118; Daley's continued dismissal and UK news in brief
ROUNDTABLE (pt. 1): What's next for B.J. Penn and Kenny Florian after their UFC 118 losses? Marsh, Hyden, Hobaugh, Leet and Hansen
THE TAPPER'S TOOLBOX: Fixing the little mistakes in your BJJ game - "How to break guard"
HYDEN BLOG: Change Can Be A Good Thing
PARK: A look at five era-changing losses by UFC Champions following B.J. Penn's UFC 118 loss to Frankie Edgar
ALL BUSINESS: The UFC 118 and Fan Expo Live Experience - Thoughts From a Fan Who Loves This Business
Interviews
STRIKEFORCE QUOTABLES: Muhammed "King Mo" Lawal says he deserved to lose to Rafael "Feijao" Cavalcante because he abandoned his gameplan
QUOTABLES: Paul Daley says UFC "God" Dana White rules the UFC with an iron rod
UFC QUOTABLES: Lightweight Champion Frankie Edgar says he's fine with fans taking time to believe in him after consecutive wins over B.J. Penn
QUOTABLES: Shaquille O'Neal says he wants to fight one MMA fight against Hong Man-Choi
BELLATOR NEWS: Travis Reddinger credits trainer Sergio Cunha for his progression; ready for "explosive" bantamweight tournament
UFC QUOTABLES: UFC welterweight and former pro boxer Marcus Davis doesn't think James Toney will be able to do anything at UFC 118
Champs & Rankings
UFC 118: Edgar vs. Penn II Prediction and Betting Contest Results
MMATorch Staff Rankings - August 2010
UFC 117 Prediction and Betting Contest Results
UFC 116: Lesnar vs. Carwin Prediction and Betting Contests Results
MMATorch Staff Rankings - July 2010
UFC 115 Prediction and Betting Contest Results
Ask the Torch
Ask MMATorch: Answers to your questions about Shamrock, Half vs. Full Guard, Hammill, UFC Pay
DVD Reviews
DVD REVIEW: "UFC: Rampage Greatest Hits" a great collection of fights for Rampage fans new and old
DVD WORLD: Pride 33 "The Second Coming" - Dan "Hollywood" Henderson vs. Wanderlei "The Axe Murderer" Silva (pt. 8)
DVD WORLD: Pride 33 "The Second Coming" - Nick Diaz vs. "The Fireball Kid" Takanori Gomi (pt. 7)
DVD WORLD: Pride 33 "The Second Coming" - Alistair "Ubereem" Overeem vs. Mauricio "Shogun" Rua (pt. 6)
DVD WORLD: Pride 33 "The Second Coming" - Sergei Kharitonov vs. Mike Russow (pt. 5)
DVD WORLD: Pride 33 "The Second Coming" - Hayato "Mach" Sakurai vs. Mac Danzig (pt. 5)
Torch Flashbacks
FLASHBACK: Keller's full fight report and more Dana White quotes on UFC's debacle of an event back in 2001
KELLER: Dana White had a night even worse than Strikeforce's on Saturday night back in 2001
FLASHBACK (3 YRS AGO): Keller's UFC 69 Report with Georges St. Pierre vs. Matt Serra, Koscheck vs. Sanchez, Huerta vs. Garcia
ENNIS (Flashback 2006): Pride vs. UFC: Which Aspects of Each Promotion Would You Keep?
FLASHBACK - 3 YRS AGO: Ennis's UFC 67 Report - Rampage and Cro Cop debut, Anderson Silva defends, Scott Smith, Roger Huerta
1 YR AGO - PENICK'S UFC 88 REPORT: Rashad Evans vs. Chuck Liddell, Rich Franklin vs. Matt Hamill, plus Hendo, Marquardt (w/star ratings)
Torch MMA Polls
MMATORCH POLL: Bellator CEO Bjorn Rebney says not all MMA fans are NFL fans. Be heard, are you a fan of one sport alone or both?
NEW MMATORCH POLL: Who should Anderson Silva face next?
POLL: Should Liddell retire or fight again? Should Cro Cop retire or fight again?
MMATORCH POLL: Which fight are you anticipating more - Lesnar vs. Carwin or Silva vs. Sonnen?
POLL: What should Paul Daley's punishment be for the post-fight cheapshot at Koscheck?
MMATORCH POLL: Who will win and how in the UFC 113 main event between Lyoto Machida and Mauricio "Shogun" Rua
Prediction and Betting Contests
UFC 118: Edgar vs. Penn II Prediction and Betting Contest Results
UFC 118 Prediction and Betting Contests
UFC 117 Prediction and Betting Contest Results
UFC 117: Silva vs. Sonnen Prediction and Betting Contests


© 1999-2010 TDH Communications Inc. • All rights reserved -- PRIVACY POLICY