MMATorch.com
CONTACT US FORUM
SEARCH PWTORCH


MMATORCH STAFF:

Supervising Editor
WADE KELLER (email)

Editor-in-Chief
JAMIE PENICK (email)

Contributors/Columnists
SHAWN ENNIS
MIKE JARSULIC
MATT PELKEY
BRUCE MITCHELL
JOHN TAYLOR
JED GOODMAN
FRANK HYDEN
JASON BENT
APPLY TO JOIN OUR TEAM

BOOKMARK US
Bookmark and Share
SUBSCRIBE TO OUR FEED
subscribe to this feed



WE ARE A PROUD UGO AFFILIATE




MMA KEY WEB LINKS
UFC's Official Site
WEC's Official Site
Versus' Official Site
EliteXC Official Site
IFL's Official Site
Rage in the Cage Site

Bodog's Official Site
FIGHT3R News Site
F
Link Exchanges Available
(contact us for details)




Opinion & Analysis : Staff Editorials
GOODMAN COLUMN: Yes & No for UFC 86: Jackson vs. Griffin
Jed I. Goodman, MMATorch Columnist
Jul 6, 2008 - 3:05:29 PM


Email This Article - Printer-Friendly Pages - Contact Us - Go to PWTorch

| subscribe to this feed

11,172 fans jam packed the Mandalay Bay Events Center in Las Vegas for UFC 86 to see two of the most popular fighters in MMA lock horns. It was a solid show with a fantastic main event. Once again, the "yeses and nos"for UFC 86

Yes to Quinton "Rampage" Jackson (28-7, 3-1 UFC, 13(T)KOs, 7 Subs) and Forrest Griffin (16-4, 7-2 UFC, 3(T)KOs, 7 Subs). Fight of the night, fight of the half year. What an awesome showing by both. If Forrest fights Chuck Liddell next for the light heavyweight title we can expect, maybe, the biggest fight in MMA PPV history. Meanwhile, for "Rampage", perhaps next up is a rematch with Mauricio Rua or Wanderlei Silva.

No to Patrick Cote (13-4, 5-4 UFC, 6(T)KOs, 3 Subs) for being ranked as the number one contender. The middleweight division is the weakest division in the UFC. Perhaps Cote has earned his shot with five straight wins, but he is clearly outmatched against Anderson Silva. I would rather see Yushin Okami as the number one contender. I think he is outmatched as well, but at least the fight can be hyped as a rematch, with Silva looking for revenge.

Yes to Josh Koscheck (11-2, 9-2 UFC, 2 (T)KOs, 4 Subs). He plays the "heel" role perfectly. He has also improved immensely since his time on TUF. There is talk of him moving down to lightweight to fight B.J. Penn. I don't like his chances in that fight, but I'd love to see it. Set it in Hawaii, so Koscheck can play heel for the perfect crowd, and you have another big fight on your hands.

Yes to Chris Lytle (25-16-5, 4-8 UFC, 4(T)KOs, 17 Subs). A true warrior and a courageous fight considering the amount of blood he lost.

No to Lytle. As courageous as he is, Lytle is not in the upper echelon of fighters, he is a gate keeper. If his sole purpose is to be a gate keeper, I suppose Dana White will keep him. If the idea is for the UFC to have the absolute best fighters, then it may be time to trim him from the roster.

Yes to Joe Stevenson (29-8, 6-2 UFC, 6(T)KOs, 13 Subs). Losing on the scorecards, Stevenson locked in a guillotine choke for the win. The move has become a favorite of his, having won three of his last four with it.

No to the UFC for having commercials on PPV. Sell advertising space on the octagon cage floor, no problem. Let Bruce Buffer announce the sponsors of the show, fine, but don't cut to a commercial, especially not for another Nicholas Cage dud.

Yes to Tyson Griffin's (12-1, 5-1 UFC, 5 (T)KOs, 3 Subs) and Gleison Tibau's (15-6, 3-3 UFC, 2(T)KOs, 7 Subs) ring music. For Tibua's fight with Stevenson he came out to Black Sabbath's Iron Man. Griffin came out to Survivor's Eye of the Tiger for his fight against Marcus Aurelio. During both fights I thought I was five years old again watching 80's wrestling. Love it.

No to the UFC for their continuous shots of "B-list" celebrities in the crowd. The NBA does a good job of making their sport look big, by focusing on the "A-list" celebrities in the arena. During the NBA Finals they showed Jack Nicholson and Denzel Washington, among the many, in the crowd. But to the UFC, stop showing me That 70s Show actors, that doesn't make the UFC look big time. Nor do I wanna see Mandy Moore. She's cute, but she's "B-list" material. If the UFC wants to get "a rub" from celebrities, focus on the big names in the crowd, if there are any, at the show. Wilmer Valderrama and Laura Prepon simply do not cut it.

No to Jorge Gurgel. Another "gate keeper" fighter, it may be time for him to move to a smaller promotion to brush up on his skills.

Yes to Melvin Guillard (22-7-2, 4-3 UFC, 14 (T)KOs, 3 Subs). After losing two in a row, one of those being to his rival Rich Clementi, Guillard left the UFC to fight for a smaller promotion. He won that fight and came back to the UFC last night in style, with a sensational knockout.

Yes to the overall show. Although there wasn't bad blood between Jackson and Griffin on TUF, like with past coaches on the show, their fight was still a dream match and it lived up to to it's potential. The undercard was solid if not spectacular.

DAILY AUDIO SHOW LISTING MMATORCH DAILY AUDIO UPDATE

RETURN TO MMA TORCH'S MAIN LISTING

REACT TO THIS STORY IN OUR FREE MMATORCH FORUM

| subscribe to this feed


Staff Editorials
RELATED ARTICLES
BENT COLUMN: UFC 89: 'TUF' Fighters, Tough Fights
BENT COLUMN: TUF 8 Episode 4: "Drunken Retards”
HYDEN COLUMN: Drawbacks To WEC Dropping Weight Classes
BENT COLUMN: Get Bent: Elite XC Heat
BENT COLUMN: TUF 8 Episode 3: "Call Me Kunta Kinte"
HYDEN COLUMN: EliteXC: Heat 10/4 Predictions
BENT COLUMN: Different Fighters, Shared Similarities: Kimbo Slice & Ken Shamrock
HYDEN COLUMN: Not Enough Fighting
BENT COLUMN: TUF 8: Straight Up Team Noguiera vs. Team Mir, Dawg.
HYDEN COLUMN: Why Lesnar vs. Couture Is/Isn't The Biggest Fight In UFC History, Part 2
HYDEN'S UFC Fight Night 15 Review
BENT COLUMN: Ultimate Fight Night 15: Worth Paying For

(c) 1999-2008 TDH Communications Inc. - All rights reserved.



MMATORCH'S MMA SCHEDULE


MMATORCH POLL

Which of these fighters, top in their weight class, is the best Pound-for-Pound fighter?
Anderson Silva
Georges St. Pierre
B.J. Penn
Fedor Emelianenko
Urijah Faber
  
VOTE IN OR SEE RESULTS OF PREVIOUS POLLS



LATEST STORIES BY CATEGORY
MMATorch Podcast
MMATORCH EXCLUSIVE: Penick's Daily Audio Update 10/15 (16 min.)
MMATORCH EXCLUSIVE: Penick's Daily Audio Update 10/14 (12 min.)
MMATORCH EXCLUSIVE: Penick's Daily Audio Update 10/10 (18 min.)
MMATORCH EXCLUSIVE: Penick's Daily Audio Update 10/9 (17 min.)
MMATORCH EXCLUSIVE: Penick's Daily Audio Update 10/07: Special EliteXC Heat Review with Bent Part 2 (22 min.)
MMATORCH EXCLUSIVE: Penick's Daily Audio Update 10/06: Special EliteXC Heat Review with Bent Part 1 (17 min.)
Upcoming Events
Ultimate Fight Night Live Contest
UFC 88 Prediction and Betting Contests!
UFC 87 Prediction and Betting Contests!
PELKEY COLUMN: Affliction and Ultimate Fight Night Previews: A Side by Side Comparison
UFC 86 Prediction and Betting Contests!
UFC 85 Prediction and Betting Contests!
MMA News
Williams' MMA News Blog: Report: Strikeforce and NBC Close to Deal for Airing Live Fights
Williams' MMA News Blog: Sanchez Off UFC 90; Koscheck to Step In vs Alves?
Williams' MMA News Blog: Fedor/Arvloski Official As Next Affliction Main Event
Williams' MMA News Blog: MMA Oddity Joe Son Charged with Multiple Felonies
Williams' MMA News Blog: Florida Launches Preliminary Investigation into Petruzelli Payout
Williams' MMA News Blog: Kos/Yoshida, Fabiano/Tamura Signed for December
PPV & TV Events
Penick's Elite XC: Heat Report 10/4: Live On-Going Coverage of CBS Event
Penick's UFC Fight Night: Diaz vs. Neer Report 9/17: Ongoing Blog of Live Spike Event
UFC 88 Contest Results!
Penick's UFC 88 Report: Live On-Going Coverage of Pay Per View from Atlanta, GA
UFC 87 Prediction and Betting Contest Results
UFC 87 ROUNDTABLE REVIEWS: Ennis, Hyden, Penick
TV Reviews
THE ULTIMATE FIGHTER REPORT: Hyden's rundown on all the fights, all the drama on Spike TV
THE ULTIMATE FIGHTER REPORT: Hyden's rundown of all the fights, all the drama on Spike TV
THE ULTIMATE FIGHTER REPORT 9/24: Hyden's rundown of all the fights, all the action on Spike TV
THE ULTIMATE FIGHTER REPORT 9/17: Hyden's rundown of all the fights, all the drama on Spike TV
THE ULTIMATE FIGHTER REPORT 6/18: Hyden's rundown of all the fights, all the drama on Spike TV
THE ULTIMATE FIGHTER REPORT 6/11: Hyden's rundown of all the fights, all the drama on Spike TV
Live Event Reports
2/29 IFL in Las Vegas results: McGivern defends against Horwich, Lindland's Team Quest vs. Ken Shamrock's Lion's Dean, more
ENNIS: Thoughts While Watching Kimbo vs. Tank (February of Shawn, Day 6)
ENNIS: Belatedly Live-Blogging Tonight's WEC Event (February of Shawn, Day 5)
7/14 Cage Rage 21 Recap of ProElite.com Webcast with Star Ratings for the Fights
ENNIS: Blogging My Way Through Fight Night
5/6 ADCC Day 2 Results - Absolute Division (Open Weight) Tournaments and Superfight Results
DVD Reviews
PENICK'S DVD REVIEW: UFC 66- Liddell v. Ortiz
DVD REVIEW: King of the Cage - Reality Stars - TUF Fighters Before They Were Stars in the UFC
DVD REVIEW: UFC 47 - First Chuck Liddell vs. Tito Ortiz Fight, Yves Edwards vs. Hermes Franca, Nick Diaz vs. Robbie Lawler
DVD REVIEW: Pride Shockwave 2004 - Fedor vs. Nogueira, Hunt vs. Silva, Gomi vs. Pulver, Henderson vs. Kondo
DVD REVIEW: UFC Ultimate Japan - Japanese Debut with Kazushi Sakuraba, Randy Couture, Frank Shamrock, Tank Abbott
DVD REVIEW: UFC 8 - David vs. Goliath tournament with debuts of Don Frye and Gary Goodridge, Shamrock-Kimo
Opinion & Analysis
BENT COLUMN: UFC 89: 'TUF' Fighters, Tough Fights
BENT COLUMN: TUF 8 Episode 4: "Drunken Retards”
HYDEN COLUMN: Drawbacks To WEC Dropping Weight Classes
BENT COLUMN: Get Bent: Elite XC Heat
BENT COLUMN: TUF 8 Episode 3: "Call Me Kunta Kinte"
HYDEN COLUMN: EliteXC: Heat 10/4 Predictions
Ask the Torch
Ask MMATorch: Answers to your questions about Shamrock, Half vs. Full Guard, Hammill, UFC Pay
Interviews
INTERVIEW HIGHLIGHTS: Frank Shamrock talks family, friction, and sport
BENT Interview: A Conversation with the King: Q&A with KJ Noons
BENT INTERVIEW: Baroni Speaks on Welterweight Fight, Post Fight Incident
MMATorch Exclusive: Penick's interview with Brandon Vera
BENT INTERVIEW: 10 questions with Phil Baroni
Interview Highlights: Frank Shamrock talks Dana White, Vince McMahon, Baroni, more
Champs & Rankings
Torch Nation UFC Rankings
UFC 86 Contests: Revision
UFC 86 Contest Results!
Return of the Torch Nation UFC rankings
UFC 85 Contest Results
MMA Torch Nation UFC Rankings - Post UFC 79
Torch Flashbacks
RETRO: Dana White talks to Torch about fallout from Vegas disaster five years ago, backstage notes
10 Yrs Ago - UFC 13 PPV: Keller's detailed original report including Vitor Belfort vs. Tank, plus Ortiz, Couture
TORCH FLASHBACK: MMA banned from PPV ten years ago this week
KELLER - Retro: To realize how far UFC has come in just five years, look to their Vegas debut
RETRO: Torch on site - UFC's disastrous return to national PPV and debut in Vegas
FLASHBACK: Extreme Fighting Battlecade PPV Report (10-18-96): Maurice Smith, Matt Hume, Lewis, Gracie
Torch MMA Polls
MMATorch Poll: Who is the best Pound for Pound fighter?
What Fight Are You Most Looking Forward to From UFC 87?
Torch Poll: What Show Will You Be Watching Saturday Night?
MMATorch Poll: After Saturdays' loss, what's next for Matt Hughes after his rematch against Matt Serra?
UFC Poll: Which of Saturday night's UFC 85 fights are you most looking forward to?
POLL: What do you want Tito Ortiz's next move to be?
Spotlight Article
MMATORCH EXCLUSIVE: Penick's Daily Audio Update 10/15 (16 min.)
MMATORCH EXCLUSIVE: Penick's Daily Audio Update 10/14 (12 min.)
MMATORCH EXCLUSIVE: Penick's Daily Audio Update 10/10 (18 min.)
MMATORCH EXCLUSIVE: Penick's Daily Audio Update 10/9 (17 min.)
MMATORCH EXCLUSIVE: Penick's Daily Audio Update 10/07: Special EliteXC Heat Review with Bent Part 2 (22 min.)
MMATORCH EXCLUSIVE: Penick's Daily Audio Update 10/06: Special EliteXC Heat Review with Bent Part 1 (17 min.)