Email This Article - Printer-Friendly Pages - Contact Us

---

FACEBOOK TWITTER RSS APP PODCAST

Jan 13, 2009 - 11:19:47 PM
By: Jamie Penick, MMATorch Editor-in-Chief
Suspended by the California State Athletic Commission following his bout in July at EliteXC: Heat, Antonio "Bigfoot" Silva has filed a civil action against MMA's governing body in the state of California. According to Sherdog.com, Silva filed for a "writ of mandate" in the Los Angeles Superior Court on January 7th. He's looking for a decision to either overrule the one year suspension handed down to him or to be allowed another hearing to "prove his innocence."

The contention from the Silva camp has been that his test came back with a false positive cause by an over-the-counter supplement Novedex. Sherdog states that Novodex is "contains the testosterone booster ATD, is currently not included on the CSAC’s list of banned substances and has been documented to cause false readings for Boldenone before." They also contend that Silva's pre-fight questionnaire was presented to him in English, and his supplement use was only marked as "multi-vitamins" on the form by his manager, and translator, Alex Davis, who was assisting him on "portions of his questionnaire."

Due to the fact that he competed in Japan on January 4th at the Sengoku 7 event, the CSAC had already scheduled a February 10th hearing set to be a review to revoke Silva's license in California. This comes down to Silva's camp feeling they were presented with the burden of proof, when it should have been the other way around from the commission; further, they contend he needed to take the fight in Japan for monetary reasons, as he's got expensive medical bills stemming from his acromegaly, which is a chronic condition that causes enlargement of the extremities and face due to an overactive pituitary gland. If this suit and their subsequent appeals to overturn the suspension are unsuccessful, Davis says Silva "will fight in Japan forever...he just doesn’t have a choice."

Link to Original Source Article

Penick's Analysis: It seems from what is presented here that what should have happened at Silva's initial appeal in October did not. Silva and his lawyers presented an independent sample that was clean to the commission, who then "questioned the validity of Silva’s independent test in regards to its authenticity and chain of custody." This before they entirely dismissed the program in which Silva was tested in December following the exit of Executive Officer Armando Garcia, and held events without testing a single participant before implementing their new and, admittedly, improved system using the "same UCLA laboratory used by NFL, minor league baseball, men’s and women’s NCAA sports, and the Dept. of Defense." This is in no way a proclamation of Silva's innocence, but the man does seem to have a legitimate case, and he's willing to fight for that in court. There's something that just feels off from the initial hearing in October to the exit of Garcia in December to the entire testing system being scrapped to implement a new one. There are too many factors to stay steadfast at the year long suspension. At the very least he made a case for a reduced punishment. We'll find out more in the coming weeks and months either way.

CLICK HERE FOR MORE UFC NEWS AND MMATORCH EXCLUSIVE FEATURES

Help support MMATorch by answering a brief anonymous demographic survey: CLICK HERE

Comment on this article below ad...

CLICK TO RETURN TO MAIN LISTING
OR CHOOSE SPECIFIC CATEGORY LISTING FROM DROP MENU

UFC AND WEC NEWS: WEC 47 and UFC 110 Numbers Down Dramatically from Recent Shows

UFC NEWS: Open tryouts coming to North Carolina on April 1st for season 12 of The Ultimate Fighter

UFC NEWS: Stephan Bonnar loses appeal of UFC 110 loss to Krzysztof Soszynski, rematch expected

WEC VIDEO: Leonard Garcia vs. George Roop "Fight of the Night" from WEC 47 released by Versus

WEC NEWS: Joseph Benavidez tops disclosed fighter salaries for WEC 47

BELLATOR NEWS: Season one lightweight runner up Toby Imada named sixth entrant in season two tourney

BELLATOR NEWS: Sean Wheelock tapped as play by play broadcaster for Bellator season 2

WEC PIC: Brian Bowles posts picture of broken hand suffered in Title loss to Dominick Cruz

WEC 47 RESULTS: Dominick Cruz claims WEC Bantamweight Championship as Brian Bowles breaks hand, doctor's stop fight after two rounds

WEC 47 BONUSES: Pettis, Benavidez, Roop and Garcia take home an extra $10K for their performances at WEC 47

WEC 47 RESULTS: Joseph Benavidez submits former WEC Bantamweight Champion Miguel Torres in bloody second round

WEC NEWS: Weigh-in results for WEC 47: Bowles vs. Cruz

MMA VIDEO: ESPN's MMA Live previews WEC 47 and addresses recent Strikeforce fight rumors

WEC NEWS: With Frank Mir training, Stephan Bonnar in on commentary at WEC 47

OTHER NEWS: Versus-DirectTV dispute reportedly coming to an end next week

WEC QUOTABLES: Jens Pulver - "Everyone always thought Pat Miletich had a magical touch and was teaching us all these magical things. No he wasn't. No. Never. Never ever."

WEC QUOTABLES: Jamie Varner says Ben Henderson fought scared, gets lucky in fights

BELLATOR NEWS: Heavyweight prospect Cole Konrad signs on with Bellator

OTHER NEWS: Tim Sylvia vs. Marius Pudzianowski set to reportedly headline April 23rd event in Worcester, MA

BELLATOR NEWS: Welterweight tournament matchups announce, first round takes place on April 15th, April 22nd events